The Difference Between Proportional Control Valves and Servo Valves

Apr 11, 2026

Leave a message

Introduction

This article outlines the work undertaken by ISO in developing a new standard for the testing of electrically modulated control valves (replacing ISO 6604 with ISO 10770-1), specifically addressing the question of what exactly distinguishes servo valves from proportional valves. To clarify this issue, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) specifically funded a project at the Fluid Power Institute of Milwaukee Institute of Technology to conduct targeted research. Over the course of a year, the project produced recommendations to resolve the standardisation issues, particularly proposing definitions for the two key terms of 'servo valve' and 'proportional valve'. Subsequently, these definitions were formally adopted as terminology and definitions within the ISO standard. This demonstrates the rigour of the ISO standard-setting process.

 

Currently, the definitions of proportional control valves and servo valves have been formally incorporated into the national standard GB/T 17446-2024, as follows:

Servo valve: An electrically modulated continuous control valve with a deadband of less than 3% of the spool stroke.

Proportional control valve: An electrically modulated continuous control valve with a deadband of 3% or more of the spool stroke.

The following text sets out the rationale provided by the authors of the standard definitions.

proportional valve

In almost every industrial training course, someone inevitably asks me: what exactly is the difference between a proportional valve and a servo valve? I rather enjoy hearing this question, as it provides us with a bit of amusement. However, the shortest answer is: I refuse to get drawn into these endless debates. The technical standard ISO 10770-1 (corresponding to GB/T 15623 'Hydraulic transmission – Electrically modulated hydraulic control valves – Part 1: Test methods for four-way directional flow control valves') provides certain definitions. Before I explain, let us first consider some historical background.

 

Authoritative Conclusion: The Sole Standard Relies on This One Indicator

The continuous growth of electronic and electrical technologies applied to various types of hydraulic systems has naturally sparked considerable interest in proportional valves and servo valves. In fact, this has not escaped the attention of the ISO Technical Committees, as they are responsible for the formulation of international technical standards, particularly ISO/TC-131/SC-8, which is tasked with the standardisation of hydraulic components.

Technical Committee TC-131 is the body within the ISO organisation specifically responsible for all fluid power standardisation. In the United States, the representative responsible for ISO standards is affiliated with ANSI (American National Standards Institute); however, ANSI has the authority to delegate its secretariat functions to other US national technical bodies. With regard to fluid power, ANSI has authorised the American National Fluid Power Organisation, based in Milwaukee.

 

The secretariat of ISO/TC-131 Subcommittee SC-8 is located at the British Standards Institution in London, which itself focuses primarily on the testing of fluid power equipment, including hydraulic valves. (The British Standards Institution Secretariat's Subcommittee 8 specialises in standard test methods for fluid power equipment, including valves. In 2000, ISO published the international standard ISO 10770-1, entitled 'Hydraulic fluid power – Electrically modulated hydraulic control valves – Part 1: Test methods for four-way directional flow control valves'. It covers test methods and rating methods for servo valves and proportional valves.)

 

In 2000, ISO published the new standard ISO 10770-1, entitled 'Hydraulic power transmission – Electrically modulated hydraulic control valves – Part 1: Test methods for four-way directional flow control valves'. It primarily covers test methods and is mainly aimed at proportional valves and servo valves. ISO 10770-1 replaced ISO 6604, which dealt solely with servo valves; consequently, ISO 10770 represents a relative improvement.

Origin of the Standard: Why 3%?

 

In 1988 and 1989, at the Fluid Power Institute of the Milwaukee School of Engineering, I led a research project focusing on the practical application of proportional and servo valves. One of the objectives was to provide definitions in the form of a glossary, or as we termed it, a vocabulary list (to provide precise definitions for proportional and servo valves).

We surveyed all known manufacturers producing such valves and summarised the most important characteristics of their products. Our aim was to identify the differences between them.

To identify the differences in their application in industrial practice, we defined the following characteristics:

Control method (pilot-operated or direct-acting)

Frequency response

Feedback method (built-in or external)

Spool travel

Valve application (for open-loop or closed-loop control)

Control accuracy

Upon completion of this study, only one factor distinguished the two: the spool travel.

This led to the following definitions of servo valves and proportional valves:

Servo valve - Any continuously variable, electrically controlled directional control valve with a stroke of less than 3%.

Proportional valve - Any continuously variable, electrically controlled directional control valve with a stroke of more than 3%.

 

Consequently, the '3%' threshold was formally incorporated into international standards, becoming a universally accepted criterion for classification. If the stroke happens to be exactly 3%, the standard states that the valve may be classified under either category, with no mandatory requirement.

These definitions were incorporated into a compendium of terminology standards and published upon completion of the project. We took this conclusion to heart and sought to introduce the terminology across various industrial contexts. Since then, whenever the opportunity arose, I have personally presented it in my own lectures, as well as at every NFPA (National Fluid Power Association) and ISO conference. To my surprise, there has been very little opposition-neither then nor now. Some have asked me: 'So, if the coverage is exactly 3%, how should it be defined?' My answer is: 'You choose for yourself.'

 

I believe the problem stems from the time when people first began using the terms 'servo valve' and 'proportional valve', without anyone having previously defined them precisely. The result was that for every specific valve, people could invent all sorts of terms out of thin air. Such definitions of terminology might be agreed upon within a single company. However, in commercial dealings, particularly international ones, it is not easy to distinguish clearly between servo valves and proportional valves. At times, this is no longer merely a technical issue, but a matter of principle.

Common pitfalls: The 'unwritten rules' of flow rate and pressure drop testing

The ISO working group responsible for developing ISO 10770-1 skilfully sidestepped certain issues, knowing that the debate would never cease. Nevertheless, the committee wished to produce a document covering both servo valves and proportional valves. But how could this be achieved without first establishing a definition? The guiding principle was clear: ISO sought to focus on a view widely accepted by the industry-namely, that proportional valves exhibit lower pressure drop compared to servo valves. Consequently, within the ISO test method standard, proportional valves are defined as valves with lower pressure drop.

 

The ISO committee decided that when defining the rated flow rate of a servo valve, the pressure drop should be 1000 PSI or 7 MPa (1015 PSI), whilst the pressure drop used to define the rated flow rate of a proportional valve should be 1 MPa or 145 PSI.

The standard contains the following sentence: 'Set the total pressure drop of the valve to 1 MPa or 7 MPa, as appropriate.' This phrase, 'depending on the circumstances', gives the impression that the ISO Standards Committee is distancing itself from the matter. Who defines 'depending on the circumstances'?

Well, it is left to the tester to decide! Consequently, they may conduct tests according to the specifications for either servo valves or proportional valves. More importantly, they are free to define the valve however they see fit. This is precisely why, in practice, we encounter proportional valves tested with a rated flow based on a pressure drop of 7 MPa. We also have 'zero-deadband proportional valves'. This is a war of semantics that no one will ever win!

Practical Guide: How should one choose, and are they interchangeable?

 

Standards merely define; they do not dictate application. When selecting in practice, three points suffice:

1. Control accuracy: Servo valves have a small deadband and high precision, suitable for high-precision closed-loop systems; proportional valves are adequate and cost-effective, suitable for conventional industrial control.

2. Response speed: Servo valves have a higher frequency response and are suitable for high-speed dynamic systems; proportional valves offer moderate response times and meet the requirements of most equipment.

3. Environment and reliability: Servo valves have high requirements for oil cleanliness and are more 'delicate'; proportional valves are highly resistant to contamination, more durable and easier to maintain.

In summary: High precision, high dynamics → servo valves; General-purpose applications, high cost-effectiveness → proportional valves.

Next time someone argues about proportional valves versus servo valves, simply refer to the national standard: deadband < 3% = servo valve, ≥ 3% = proportional valve.

Authority prevents arguments; professionalism prevents confusion.

 

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

Send Inquiry